The following article appeared in The Warwick Advertiser, a local newspaper in Orange County, New York, on Friday, February 20, 2009. I am going to grade the stimulus plan, much as a high school teacher might grade a homework assignment. The New York delegation, in particular, think they are very smart. Lets see how they did on this little project. For each answer, the grade will be “E” if it is something that is likely to stimulate the Economic growth by creation of jobs, or “G” if it likely to stimulate Government growth via expansion or creation of liberal social engineering programs. If there are more E’s than G’s, Congress gets an “A,” but if there are more G’s than E’s, Congress gets an “F.”
Early details for NY in stimulus packageBy The Associated Press
According to U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer, the economic stimulus package, subject to final congressional approval, contains roughly $20 billion for New Yorkers over 27 months, including:
$8.6 billion of additional Medicaid money for the state, $2.8 billion for New York City, $929 million for upstate counties and $262 million for Long Island.
G$2.7 billion in stabilization funds for education
G$800 million for special education funding
G$1 billion Title 1 education funding
G
$87.5 million for drinking water projects
E$439 million for sewage projects
E $1 billion for highway funding
E$1.3 billion for mass transit
E$403 million for weatherization
E$96 million for hiring extra police
G$390 million for the public housing capital fund in New York City
G$98 million for community development block grants for the state
G$142 million for homelessness prevention
G$251 million for governments and community groups to offer affordable housing and rental assistance to the poor
GCollege tuition tax benefit up to $2,500 per student for middle-class taxpayers
GTotals: 10 G’s, 5 E’sLooks like Congress fails again. So its back to middle school for all of them, including Chuck Schumer. I think I was pretty generous with the E’s, too. Mass transit? An economic stimulus? Give me a break. It certainly will not help us in upstate New York. But I have to confess something: I am no Bobby Jindal. If they offer me a $2500. Tax break for my daughter’s college tuition, I am not going to refuse it.